[{"entity":{"id":"epistemic-integrity","text":"Epistemic integrity of the write-up — honest failure modes, quantified claims, falsifiable milestones; whether the proposal reasons transparently rather than selling.","hash":"e04b1ec90d6b22c01dd0ae62abdf8248a88e69fc93a4752e9afef0dd81dd18b5"},"attribute":{"lens":"manifund-goals","axis_key":"importance-for-field-building","axis_prompt":"importance of this evaluation criterion to a grantmaker whose aim is building a healthy research field: talent pipelines, institutions, and community infrastructure","axis_prompt_hash":"2993e09eef14907304d70460fc85c1a445370acee35d822fe613382fe81aed66"},"estimate":{"point":0.5596157878421532,"interval":{"lower":-0.02029945032646774,"upper":1.139531026010774,"coverage":0.95,"method":"normal_approximation"},"distribution":{"family":"normal_approximation","mean":0.5596157878421532,"stddev":0.2958751215146025}},"context":{"rank":3,"percentile":0.875,"z_score":0.0,"cohort_size":4,"scored_at":"2026-08-20T03:38:21.422000Z"},"provenance":{"run_id":"jrun_45490546a25f4a38923106df8b3cba03","model":"anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5","harness":"cardinal-harness","harness_version":"0.9.0","temperature":0.0,"seed":"6238437735185814955","comparison_budget":32,"comparisons_used":32,"stop_reason":"budget_exhausted","topk_error":0.5300172288545258,"run_cost_nanodollars":71513000}},{"entity":{"id":"impact-per-marginal-dollar","text":"Expected impact per marginal dollar at the stated ask — how much good the next dollar of funding actually buys, given the project size, cost structure, and counterfactual funding landscape.","hash":"cb4dcce8e9b7453361e8b47fca82e52403d66fa97347e0afbc945a615f70952b"},"attribute":{"lens":"manifund-goals","axis_key":"importance-for-field-building","axis_prompt":"importance of this evaluation criterion to a grantmaker whose aim is building a healthy research field: talent pipelines, institutions, and community infrastructure","axis_prompt_hash":"2993e09eef14907304d70460fc85c1a445370acee35d822fe613382fe81aed66"},"estimate":{"point":0.0,"interval":{"lower":-0.5964090070247335,"upper":0.5964090070247335,"coverage":0.95,"method":"normal_approximation"},"distribution":{"family":"normal_approximation","mean":0.0,"stddev":0.30429030970649673}},"context":{"rank":4,"percentile":0.125,"z_score":-2.3094010767585034,"cohort_size":4,"scored_at":"2026-08-20T03:38:21.422000Z"},"provenance":{"run_id":"jrun_45490546a25f4a38923106df8b3cba03","model":"anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5","harness":"cardinal-harness","harness_version":"0.9.0","temperature":0.0,"seed":"6238437735185814955","comparison_budget":32,"comparisons_used":32,"stop_reason":"budget_exhausted","topk_error":0.5300172288545258,"run_cost_nanodollars":71513000}},{"entity":{"id":"team-track-record-evidence","text":"Verifiable track-record evidence the team can execute — concrete, checkable prior work demonstrating the team has shipped comparable things before.","hash":"81414bf71fe6723ed7b5db50efb8cd77d6d0e130ce91ddb0caca23116af5d69d"},"attribute":{"lens":"manifund-goals","axis_key":"importance-for-field-building","axis_prompt":"importance of this evaluation criterion to a grantmaker whose aim is building a healthy research field: talent pipelines, institutions, and community infrastructure","axis_prompt_hash":"2993e09eef14907304d70460fc85c1a445370acee35d822fe613382fe81aed66"},"estimate":{"point":0.5596157878421532,"interval":{"lower":-0.02029945032646774,"upper":1.139531026010774,"coverage":0.95,"method":"normal_approximation"},"distribution":{"family":"normal_approximation","mean":0.5596157878421532,"stddev":0.2958751215146025}},"context":{"rank":2,"percentile":0.625,"z_score":0.0,"cohort_size":4,"scored_at":"2026-08-20T03:38:21.422000Z"},"provenance":{"run_id":"jrun_45490546a25f4a38923106df8b3cba03","model":"anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5","harness":"cardinal-harness","harness_version":"0.9.0","temperature":0.0,"seed":"6238437735185814955","comparison_budget":32,"comparisons_used":32,"stop_reason":"budget_exhausted","topk_error":0.5300172288545258,"run_cost_nanodollars":71513000}},{"entity":{"id":"theory-of-change-plausibility","text":"Plausibility of the causal path from activities to claimed impact — whether the mechanism connecting what the team will do to the outcome they promise survives scrutiny step by step.","hash":"6ae6ea69fbbe33e7c78901720d93b2d2333cea3641c517073fab0f2edf762afa"},"attribute":{"lens":"manifund-goals","axis_key":"importance-for-field-building","axis_prompt":"importance of this evaluation criterion to a grantmaker whose aim is building a healthy research field: talent pipelines, institutions, and community infrastructure","axis_prompt_hash":"2993e09eef14907304d70460fc85c1a445370acee35d822fe613382fe81aed66"},"estimate":{"point":0.5596157878421532,"interval":{"lower":-0.03679321918258038,"upper":1.1560247948668867,"coverage":0.95,"method":"normal_approximation"},"distribution":{"family":"normal_approximation","mean":0.5596157878421532,"stddev":0.30429030970649673}},"context":{"rank":1,"percentile":0.375,"z_score":0.0,"cohort_size":4,"scored_at":"2026-08-20T03:38:21.422000Z"},"provenance":{"run_id":"jrun_45490546a25f4a38923106df8b3cba03","model":"anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5","harness":"cardinal-harness","harness_version":"0.9.0","temperature":0.0,"seed":"6238437735185814955","comparison_budget":32,"comparisons_used":32,"stop_reason":"budget_exhausted","topk_error":0.5300172288545258,"run_cost_nanodollars":71513000}}]